Advertisement
Better yet, a sincere misunderstanding, begun long ago? A true intention, but crooked, not straight.
What if the truth is available freely, right now?
Do you want it?
What will you do to get it?
See how quickly the truth can be subjugated to serve some delusionary purpose?
How quickly illusionary hurdles arise between you and that?
Or is the root of the issue, this you I'm speaking too?
Is there really such a thing, as you?
What if the truth is available freely, right now?
Do you want it?
What will you do to get it?
See how quickly the truth can be subjugated to serve some delusionary purpose?
How quickly illusionary hurdles arise between you and that?
Or is the root of the issue, this you I'm speaking too?
Is there really such a thing, as you?
posted by:
|
|
Unsubscribed |
Advertisement
Advertisement
-
Re: What if practice is a lie?
Sun, August 27, 2006 - 10:05 AMGood question.
The idea of practice seems to imply there is some thing that can be done, someone to do it and possibly a "better/worse" way.
I don't see it that way IN REALITY, though in the dreamstate it appears that way. How odd! But, this is why I do not "teach" a technique. I express my experience and disciveries and encourage others to look inside. All answers are there:
Who Am I, What is the nature of perception, what do I beleive and is it provable. How do I know? How do I know I know. what do I know FOR SURE.
If one TRULY gets what ND ultimately points to, then no, there is no practice, no one to do the practice and nothing to be attained. There is no separate self. indeed, there is no self. The self is a convenient mental abastraction that has no location, cannot be found.
Or can it? LOL Don't take my word for it - or anyone else's! Go find out for yourself (to your point/question.....we are right back where we started there is the appearance of seeking....)
I think some people here (and elsewhere) think awakening is a "practical skill" - like fixing a truck or doing surgery - and a rational, logical, scientific appraich is better then something else. Who really knows or can say for sure. Talk is cheap.
And, maybe this gets to the ND/D split - once the illusion is seen through the apparent spilt is healed and one never has an issue with negotiating between the levels again. When I see people getting "stuck" at a level or meaning or concept, or practice, I think it is because the egoic ND/D split has not been resolved - they have not really had the persepctive shift. But, This is all BS, of course ;-)
>>What if the truth is available freely, right now?
Within the context of the question ( and I would suggest looking at the assuptions needed to form the question - these define/constrain the form of the answer) I see the truth is ALWAYS here. How can it NOT be? So, I see "the search" as letting go of/learning to ignore the distractions we create for ourselves to avoid seeing the truth - amnesia, intentional ignorance, willing suspension of disbelief - call it what you will. Either by (apparent) practice of self-inquiry or suddenly, the truth is noticed and one cannot remain ignorant any longer. Its subtle touch, the footprints in the snow, are there forever more.
So, it is a not a process of adding, it is taking away - belief, concept, story, distraction.
It's like you are driving around in your car looking feverishly for who is driving you car and people keep telling you - It's YOU and you don't/won't believe them and keep going.
Oh! And the seeking is not a "choice"Of course - one seeks until one stops seeking:
wakethemup.org/bb/viewtopic.php
So, the ONE appears to itself saying it wants (a practice) to awaken and says to itself there is no practice and no one to awaken. Makes one's head spin. Which,IMHO is the point! I think one must go a little "crazy" ...
These posts may be on topic:
wakethemup.org/bb/viewtopic.php
wakethemup.org/bb/viewtopic.php
wakethemup.org/bb/viewtopic.php
wakethemup.org/bb/viewtopic.php -
-
Re: What if practice is a lie?
Sun, August 27, 2006 - 1:04 PM"I don't see it that way IN REALITY, though in the dreamstate it appears that way. How odd!"
The funny thing about dreams is that once you realize you are dreaming then you can take control of the dream...
Life is but a dream... -
-
Re: What if practice is a lie?
Sun, August 27, 2006 - 4:23 PMReally? I am not consciously aware of taking control of the dream. Perhaps I just don't want to and am content to accept what appears before me. Like in American beauty - I want the LEAST responsibility possible....
BUT, do you really WANT TO?
Did you see the movie Bruce Almighty?
wakethemup.org/bb/viewtopic.php
Can you give an example from your own life where you take control of the dream? -
-
Re: What if practice is a lie?
Sun, August 27, 2006 - 9:56 PMFirewalking is good example... The hardest part is truly accepting that it is a dream... to unlearn what you have learned... and accepting the responsibility that goes along with it -
-
Re: What if practice is a lie?
Wed, August 30, 2006 - 3:35 AM<<<Jubal wrote: "...Firewalking is good example... The hardest part is truly accepting that it is a dream... to unlearn what you have learned... and accepting the responsibility that goes along with it">>>
Good point. Anyone ever tried fire-sitting, or fire-sleeping? That would REALLY show that life is but a dream... -
-
Re: What if practice is a lie?
Wed, August 30, 2006 - 4:21 PMlol! I thought you were unsubbing?
Have you ever tried firewalking Francesco? I highly recommend it... you will never be the same...
Fear is the only obstacle -
-
Re: What if practice is a lie?
Thu, August 31, 2006 - 1:05 AMUnsubbing?... O - unsubscribing! When did you see me post such nonsense? I think thou confuseth me with yonder sage that goes by the name of Jerry. -
-
Re: What if practice is a lie?
Thu, August 31, 2006 - 5:32 PMwoops ~8P yeah you're right... jerry
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Re: What if practice is a lie?
Wed, August 30, 2006 - 6:01 AMGood question, I think practice can be relavant at some level, it also depends of what you mean by practice. If we use practice to attain a certain goal in the future, to be more complete I think that might be an illusion and therefore a lie, if we call it that :)
If we are able to forget the result of the practice and if we are practicing to be here and now, doing exactly what we are doing, it can be any of the daily stuff as it might be meditation or sth like that, I think that is helpfull.
If we practice the now, then we will perhaps realize that we are complete here and now and don´t need any practice.
Peaza! -
-
Re: What if practice is a lie?
Wed, August 30, 2006 - 4:13 PM"Don't think you can attain total awareness and whole enlightenment without proper discipline and practice.
This is egomania.
Appropriate rituals channel your emotions and life energy toward the light.
Without the discipline to practice them,
you will tumble constantly backward into darkness.
Here is the great secret:
Just as high awareness of the subtle truth is gained through virtuous conduct and sustaining disciplines, so also is it maintained through these things.
Highly evolved beings know and respect the truth of this."
-Lao Tzu -
-
Re: What if practice is a lie?
Fri, September 1, 2006 - 12:36 AMLao Tszu Rocks -
-
Re: What if practice is a lie?
Mon, October 2, 2006 - 6:41 AMIn seeing an answer to your question, I think some good questions to ask are: who is the one who wants to do the practising? Who is the one who wants to be enlightened? Who is the one motivating all this? Doesn't the need to practice imply the underlying belief that one is separate from the source, thereby enforcing yet another duality?
The process of practice itself might be closer to the truth: the practice is the practised, but then again this can be done with anything in life - a kind of Dzogchen meditation. Personally I don't think you can find enlightenment in any thing. Any need to do anything is motivated by an insecurity. You are your own enlightnement. Perhaps the "I" we create for ourselves is the key. Who created the "I" and why?
-
-
Re: What if practice is a lie?
Mon, October 2, 2006 - 3:04 PMCellarDoor - I agree. So why can't we just forget about this enlightenment stuff and get on with our lifes?
This era is a mix of unprecedented power and opportunity coupled with the most appalling vilence and sadism. And here we have the cream of our society sitting on their behinds, discussing at great lengths the advantage of being MORE passive, in the hope that they may fine-tune their sad little ego's to a much-hoped for 'release' from what some call the "hell" of their regular existence.
Jesus f*cking H. Christ on a bicycle. -
-
Re: What if practice is a lie?
Mon, October 2, 2006 - 3:05 PMvilence? I meant of course "violence".
-
Re: What if practice is a lie?
Mon, October 2, 2006 - 3:51 PMtakes a lot of effort to lie to yourselfe that everything is hunky-dory while the world is destroying itself. Kinda funny if your not connected and not connected you wanna be or atleast you claim it to be a choise and for your children or whatever flesh and bone principles it takes.
to avoid doing anything when the challenge is brought at your feet is laying to yourselfe. And these days the hard part is that the challenge is always at your feet. Where we are right now is the crossroad of choises. And falling back into the Tao or whatever is a chosie by the way however you choose to twist and weld it. Im not saying that it is a bad one but it is a nothing to lose nothing to gain situation - a safe way out of this world. what should we do to gain some plusses for are stay here.. those who know the way.. or atleast would be open enaugh to recognize the path when it's time to get da f**k off this planet. I have no clue.
-
Unsu...
Re: What if practice is a lie?
Tue, October 3, 2006 - 10:16 AMGreat comment Fran. It's true. Enlightenment is a trance induction. You are a hyponotized zombie if you are searching for enlightenment, or any other state that is bent on your own personal satisfaction. So, being aware of the state of things here on the planet, as it sounds like you are, what are you doing with your life?
Actually, anyone can answer this question, what are you doing with your life? And save the nondual, double speak. It doesn't work on everybody.
Cheers. -
-
Re: What if practice is a lie?
Tue, October 3, 2006 - 12:13 PMI'm a psychotherapist/psychologist working with victims of war - mainly traumatized refugees from countries like Afghanistan, Irak, Iran, DRC, ex-Yugoslavia, etc. etc. It does give me satisfaction, but doesn't make me a better person . As one of my patients explained to me: "you've got a good secure job and you sit on your behind all day". But it beats just working to add to my possessions (be they material or spiritual).
-
Re: What if practice is a lie?
Tue, October 3, 2006 - 12:14 PM<<<Robert wrote: "...Enlightenment is a trance induction. You are a hyponotized zombie if you are searching for enlightenment, or any other state that is bent on your own personal satisfaction...">>>
100% agreement from my side. -
-
If you can't find the answers within...
Tue, October 3, 2006 - 3:37 PM...then where else do you expect to find them?
-
Unsu...
Re: What if practice is a lie?
Tue, October 3, 2006 - 5:48 PMSounds like really good work to me. Thanks for sharing.
-
-
Re: What if practice is a lie?
Wed, February 7, 2007 - 11:23 PM"Or is the root of the issue, this you I'm speaking too?
Is there really such a thing, as you?" Robert
it sounds to me like you are the one seeking enlightenment here. you have the questions.
those are "deep" questions usually asked by someone who is "seeking" enlightenment.
just wondering if you noticed.... or are you beyond enlightenment and you are trying to help us?
and then you go on calling people zombies for seeking truth. c'mon -
-
Re: What if practice is a lie?
Thu, February 8, 2007 - 2:48 PMWhat if your practice is the truth - the real reality,
and life is a strange dream or lie of sorts?
No doubt the truly enlightened experience a deeper reality
than our day to day frustrations.
-
-
This is the maximum depth. Additional responses will not be threaded.
Re: What if practice is a lie?
Mon, February 19, 2007 - 3:37 AMAndrew, possibly you could answer your question with another question? How would you go about bringing your practice into your life?
Also, what if who you consider to be the truly enlightened ones merely have you believing they are the truly enlightened...
What if the mere concept of true and continuous enlightenment was but a dream?
-
This is the maximum depth. Additional responses will not be threaded.
Re: What if practice is a lie?
Mon, February 19, 2007 - 3:38 AMAndrew, possibly you could answer your question with another question? How would you go about bringing your practice into your life?
Also, what if who you consider to be the truly enlightened ones merely have you believing they are the truly enlightened...
What if the mere concept of true and continuous enlightenment was but a dream?
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Re: What if practice is a lie?
Mon, February 19, 2007 - 4:25 AMsounds like your dealing with a deeper question here .."What if everything is a lie?" cose isn't everything a practise of some sorts.
But there is no lie or truth that you can benefit from. Just like talking is practise and dreaming or driking coffe and thinking about things you have to do and dealing with that - it's just being a being.
example:
Calling something practise and beLIEving it to be so and investing into it IS being drapped cose there is no such thing. Shareing this with others, asking a questions about it and loosing a control over your "understanding" of "practise" and it changes into formless subjective idea that means nothing.
-
Re: What if practice is a lie?
Thu, August 14, 2008 - 2:09 AMLie and false ego are of the devil. The rare illuminated and the simple, howewver, retained or resurfaced the original human mind.
-
Re: What if practice is a lie?
Thu, August 21, 2008 - 10:01 PMi would not call it a lie...
i waould call it a series of excersises designed to get the student to the point where they are no longer a buddhist...
the Masters job is to get you to the poin to where you can 'enlighten' yourself.
YOu are trained and taught until your worldview changes, then you say, i just changed my world view, how is this world view any more true thne the old one...
at this point at least for me i stopped being a Buddhist, because in order to get to the place i already was i had to let go of that worldview too.
in the end you have to drop everything, everything including your masters teachings...
then it gets interesting, very interesting
k
-
Re: What if practice is a lie?
Wed, October 29, 2008 - 1:24 PMbut the "practice" should, although we can`t seem to allow it to be so, be easier than falling off of the proverbial bicycle. we seek the ground of all things, the no-thing that is the becoming of all things.if you would look carefully you will see that the real you is the same no-thing seeking itself. so the more that you don`t identify with is exactly how it has to be until you id with non of it. you are the no - thing simply enjoying being all that it can be, the immortal wearing a mortal skin. you`ll get it, an eye without the use of a mirror cannot see itself, all of creation is that mirror
